Transfer of Property of the Deceased to the Ownership of Public Legal Entities

Keywords: public legal entities, state, territorial community, inheritance, property of the deceased, recognition of inheritance as fictitious

Abstract

Public law entities such as the state and the territorial community have been found to have general grounds for acquiring ownership of property left after the death of an individual in the following cases: they are indicated in the will as an heir; the heir waives the share due to him/her in favor of the state or territorial community. In addition, each of these entities has grounds for acquiring (inheriting) the property of the deceased, relating exclusively to him-her. Thus, a territorial community becomes the successor of the property of the deceased person, in respect of whom there were no heirs after being recognized by court as fictitious in the manner prescribed by law. The property of the deceased may pass to the state in two other cases: the inheritance was opened before July 1, 2003, but was not accepted by any of the heirs (according to article 555 of the Civil Code of Ukraine of 1963); The state of Ukraine is the heir to international treaties. It is established that the latter ground is not mentioned in the Civil Code of Ukraine, which is assessed as a gap in legislation. A detailed analysis of all the mentioned grounds for the acquisition of property of the deceased is carried out. The conclusion is confirmed that the transition to a territorial community of fizzy inheritance is not inheritance. The possibility of submitting an application to the court for recognition of the inheritance as a fictitious body of the prosecutor’s office in the interests of the territorial community, which usually occurs with the inaction of the local government, is justified. The following features of the recognition of inheritance as a fictitious property are highlighted: 1) the rules of law that fix the transition of the hereditary mass to the favor of the territorial community are mandatory in nature, that is, the local government body in its interests is obliged to apply to the court; 2) only one participant in civil legal relations — the territorial community acquires property that has not been inherited; 3) there is no limitation (maximum period) on the moment for appeal to the court; 4) to recognize the inheritance as fictitious, a person needs an appropriate court decision that has entered into legal force. It is proposed to supplement the Civil Code of Ukraine with article 12771 on the transfer to the state of inheritance discovered abroad.

References

Kushneruk, D. V. (2018) Nabuttia derzhavoiu prava vlasnosti na maino v poriadku spadkuvannia. In Ulianova, H. O. (ed.) Pravovi ta instytutsiini mekhanizmy zabezpechennia rozvytku Ukrainy v umovakh yevropeiskoi intehratsii : materialy Mizhn. nauk.-prakt. konf. (m. Odesa, 18 travnia 2018 r.) [u 2-kh t., pp. 521–523]. Odesa : Helvetyka.

Bettenfeld, F., Imamgayazova, D. (19.09.2012) Kogda nasledstvo v Germanii dostayetsya gosudarstvu. Retrieved from Deutsche Welle: https://bit.ly/3yfMspv.

Logvin, R. B. (2016) Gosudarstvo kak subyekt nasledstvennogo prava. Zakonnost i pravoporyadok v sovremennom obshchestve, 30, 13–16.

Shvedkova, O. V. (2012) Uchastiye publichnykh obrazovaniy v nasledstvennom pravopreyemstve. Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatelstve, 6, 86–91

Boryslavska, M. V. (2020) Pravovi ta istorychni peredumovy nabuttia (spadkuvannia) maina pomerloi osoby publichno-pravovymy utvorenniamy. Universytetski naukovi zapysky, 3–4 (75–76), 125–137. https://doi.org/10.37491/UNZ.75-76.14.

Spasybo-Fatieieva, I. V. (ed.) (2010) Tsyvilnyi kodeks Ukrainy: Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar (poiasnennia, tlumachennia, rekomendatsii z vykorystanniam pozytsii vyshchykh sudovykh instantsii, Ministerstva yustytsii, naukovtsiv, fakhivtsiv) (T. 1: Zahalni polozhennia). Kharkiv : FO-P Kolisnyk A. A.

Zaika, Yu. O., Riabokon, Ye. O. (2009) Spadkove pravo (O. V. Dzerа, ed.). Kyiv : Yurinkom Inter.

Postanova Lvivskoho apeliatsiinoho sudu vid 06.11.2018 r. u spravi № 453/976/18. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3wkYiwQ.

Rishennia Shostkynskoho miskraionnoho sudu Sumskoi oblasti vid 04.08.2016 r. u spravi № 589/2922/16-ts. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3wosbfL.

Rishennia Lutuhynskoho raionnoho sudu Luhanskoi oblasti vid 08.10.2013 r. u spravi № 416/3355/13-ts. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/2Sd4QPq.

Rishennia Nikopolskoo miskraionnoho sudu Dnipropetrovskoi oblasti vid 22.07.2013 r. u spravi № 182/5560/13-ts. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3bHfsgi.

Rishennia Khorolskoho raionnoho sudu Poltavskoi oblasti vid 27.03.2013 r. u spravi № 548/467/13-ts. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3hDxq6Z.

Valakh, V. V. (2009) Porivnialno-pravova kharakterystyka spadkovykh pravovidnosyn v Ukraini ta zarubizhnykh krainakh (Rosiiskii Federatsii, Frantsii, Nimechchyni, SShA). Kyiv.

Kotukhova, M. V. (2007) Grazhdansko-pravovoye regulirovaniye otnosheniy s vymorochnym imushchestvom v nasledstvennom prave Rossiyskoy Federatsii. Moskva.

Rishennia Kotovskoho miskraionnoho sudu Odeskoi oblasti vid 24.03.2014 r. u spravi № 505/662/14-ts. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3u17fK9.

Rishennia Khorolskoho raionnoho sudu Poltavskoi oblasti vid 13.03.2013 r. u spravi № 548/386/13-ts. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3wfEsTF.

Pro derzhavnu reiestratsiiu aktiv tsyvilnoho stanu. Zakon Ukrainy vid 01.07.2010 r. № 2398–VI. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/2RxrMbR.

Pravyla reiestratsii aktiv tsyvilnoho stanu v Ukraini. Zatv. nakazom Ministerstva yustytsii vid 18.10.2000 r. № 52/5, u red. nakazu Ministerstva yustytsii vid 22.11.2007 r. № 1154/5. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3bHfKno.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2012 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3tWdYFa.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2013 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/2RvCVKo.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2014 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3v3tCjq.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2015 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3ynjDYc.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2016 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3hFmsxJ.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2017 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3bEU23g.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2018 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3tQdFMh.

Zvit sudiv pershoi instantsii pro rozghliad sprav u poriadku tsyvilnoho sudochynstva za 2019 rik. (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/2NO2oNd.

Ukhvala Novohrodivskoho miskoho sudu Donetskoi oblasti vid 13.09.2017 r. u spravi № 239/369/17. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/341tSnb.

Ukhvala Zhovtnevoho raionnoho sudu m. Mariupolia vid 02.08.2012 r. u spravi № 2o/0519/144/12. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3yoUHQg.

Honhalo, R. F. (2012) Deiaki suchasni aspekty uchasti derzhav u rozghliadi sprav shchodo spadkuvannia za zakonom. Naukovi pratsi Natsionalnoho universytetu «Odeska yurydychna akademiia», 12, 321–328.

Uzahalnennia sudovoi praktyky rozghliadu tsyvilnykh sprav pro spadkuvannia. Sudova palata u tsyvilnykh spravakh apeliatsiinoho sudu Zaporizkoi oblasti. (m. Zaporizhzhia, 30.04.2009 r.). (N.d.) Retrieved from Sudova vlada Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3yiJjW1.

Pro sudovu praktyku rozghliadu tsyvilnykh sprav pro spadkuvannia: Lyst Vyshchoho spetsializovanoho sudu Ukrainy z rozghliadu tsyvilnykh ta kryminalnykh sprav. Lyst vid 16.05.2013 r. № 24-753/0/4-13. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3u075Tm.

Spadshchyna mozhe pereity u derzhavnu vlasnist, yakshcho vona vidkrylasia v period z 1 sichnia do 1 lypnia 2003 roku. (2014) Zemelnyi visnyk, 5, 1. (N.d.) Retrieved from Natsionalna biblioteka Ukrainy im. V. I. Vernadskoho: https://bit.ly/33XNys1.

Rishennia Lysychanskoho miskoho sudu Luhanskoi oblasti vid 11.07.2011 r. u spravi № 2-o-179/2011. (N.d.) Retrieved from Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen: https://bit.ly/3eYTNSL.

Horian, E. V., Kuzyk, I. I. (2012) Problemy vrehuliuvannia perekhodu spadshchyny do derzhavy u mizhnarodnomu pryvatnomu pravi. Akademiia advokatury Ukrainy, 15 (2), 1–5.

Metodychni rekomendatsii shchodo vchynennia notarialnykh dii, poviazanykh iz vzhyttiam zakhodiv shchodo okhorony spadkovoho maina, vydacheiu svidotstv pro pravo na spadshchynu ta svidotstv pro pravo vlasnosti na chastku v spilnomu maini podruzhzhia. Skhv. rishenniam Naukovo-ekspertnoi rady z pytan notariatu pry Ministerstvi yustytsii Ukrainy vid 29.01.2009 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3wjYTyN.

Pro mizhnarodne pryvatne pravo. Zakon Ukrainy vid 23.06.2005 r. № 2709–IV. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3wjYUCR.

Konventsiia pro pravovu dopomohu i pravovi vidnosyny u tsyvilnykh, simeinykh ta kryminalnykh spravakh vid 22.01.1993 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3fpXOi4.

Mizhnarodni dohovory Ukrainy pro pravovi vidnosyny ta pravovu dopomohu (u 2 t., t. 1). (2004) Kyiv : In Yure.

Dohovir mizh Ukrainoiu ta Cheskoiu Respublikoiu pro pravovu dopomohu v tsyvilnykh spravakh vid 28.05.2001 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3yiJCjD.

Dohovir mizh Ukrainoiu ta Latviiskoiu Respublikoiu pro pravovu dopomohu ta pravovi vidnosyny u tsyvilnykh, simeinykh, trudovykh ta kryminalnykh spravakh vid 23.05.1995 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3hDG5GB.

Dohovir mizh Ukrainoiu ta Rumuniieiu pro pravovu dopomohu ta pravovi vidnosyny v tsyvilnykh spravakh vid 30.01.2002 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3bDPwlD.

Dohovir mizh Ukrainoiu i Respublikoiu Moldova pro pravovu dopomohu ta pravovi vidnosyny u tsyvilnykh i kryminalnykh spravakh vid 13.12.1993 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3bDT5Zc.

Dohovir mizh Ukrainoiu i Respublikoiu Polshcha pro pravovu dopomohu ta pravovi vidnosyny u tsyvilnykh i kryminalnykh spravakh vid 24.05.1993 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/3bB9wVN.

Uhoda mizh Ukrainoiu ta Turetskoiu Respublikoiu pro pravovu dopomohu ta spivrobitnytstvo u tsyvilnykh spravakh vid 23.11.2000 r. (N.d.) Retrieved from Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. Zakonodavstvo Ukrainy: https://bit.ly/2S9fpCK.

Published
2020-12-31
Section
Law