Applicability of International Treaties in a Criminal Procedure: the Case of Belarus

Keywords: international treaty, international legal assistance, human rights, consular conventions, criminal procedure, source of law

Abstract

The article indicates that the norms of international treaties can be a legal basis for making decisions in the course of criminal procedural activities, serve as a message in the formation and formulation of a legal position by participants in criminal proceedings. The absence of general regulation of the rules of interaction between the criminal procedure law and international treaties of the Republic of Belarus was established. Attention is drawn to the fact that a self-executing international treaty, permitted for application on the territory of Belarus by an internal legal act, is included in the system of sources of criminal procedural law of the Republic of Belarus. The norms of such an international treaty can be applied in the course of criminal proceedings, acting practically as special in relation to the rules of the Belarusian legislation. The text of the Criminal Procedure Code of Belarus contains a number of norms referring to international treaties regulating certain specific issues. Several varieties of such partial references have been identified. The article reveals a range of international treaties, that should by mandatory applicable within criminal proceedings due to explicit reference in the Criminal Procedure Code of Belarus (defining human rights and freedoms; containing norms on the procedure for providing international legal assistance in criminal matters; regulating civil proceedings). Other international treaties have been identified, which in their essence can be applied within criminal proceedings in Belarus, and sometimes their norms can replace the corresponding national criminal procedural norms. The need to take into account the norms of consular conventions, which contain criminal procedural norms (for example, on the right of a detainee to consular assistance), was especially noted. Due to the lack of a general reference to international treaties in the Criminal Procedure Code of Belarus, based on the principle of pacta sunt servanda, it is indicated that there is an unacceptable legislative encumbrance on the application of such treaties. In the course of the research, general conditions for the applicability of an international treaty within the criminal proceedings of the Republic of Belarus were formulated.

References

Danilevich, A. A.; Petrova, O. V.; & Samarin, V. I. Ugolovnyj process. Minsk : BGU.

Marchenko, M. N. (ed.) (2005) Istochniki rossijskogo prava. Voprosy teorii i istorii. Moskva : Norma-M.

Marchenko, M. N. (2005) Istochniki prava. Moskva : Prospekt.

Biryukov, P. N. (2006) Mezhdunarodnoe pravo. 3rd ed. Moskva : Yurist.

Zivs, S. L. (1981) Istochniki prava. Moskva : Nauka.

Gavrilov, V. V. (2001) Teorii transformacii i implementacii norm mezhdunarodnogo prava v otechestvennoj pravovoj doktrine. Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava, 2, 39–61.

Zimnenko, B. L. (2000) Mezhdunarodnoe pravo i rossijskoe pravo: ih sootnoshenie. Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava, 3, 162–168.

Bekyashev, K. A. (ed.) (2008) Mezhdunarodnoe publichnoe pravo. 4th ed. Moskva : Prospekt.

Klein, E. (1988) Unmittelbare Geltung, Anwendbarkeit und Wirkung von europaischem Gemeinschaftsrecht. Vortrag vor dem Europa-Institut der Universitat des Saarlandes / Europa-Institut der Universitat des Saarlandes. Saarbrucken : Europa-Institut der Universitat des Saarlandes. URL : https://bit.ly/3N20MbO.

Wengler, W. (1964) Volkerrecht. Enzyklopadie der Rechts und Staatswissenschaft. Berlin : Springer.

Chernichenko, S. V. (1974) Lichnost i mezhdunarodnoe pravo. Moskva : Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya.

Getman-Pavlova, I. V.; Postnikova, E. V. (2019) Mezhdunarodnoe pravo. 3rd ed. Moskva : Yurajt.

Meshanova, M. V. (2017) Sistemnost v mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave. Minsk : Chetyre chetverti.

Myullerson, R. A. (1982) Sootnoshenie mezhdunarodnogo i nacionalnogo prava. Moskva : Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya.

Mironov, N. V. (1968) Sovetskoe zakonodatelstvo i mezhdunarodnoe pravo. Moskva : Mezhdunar. otnosheniya.

Brovka, Yu. P.; Lepeshkov, Yu. A.;. Pavlova, L. V. (eds.) (2010) Mezhdunarodnoe publichnoe pravo. Obshaya chast. Minsk : Amalfeya.

Opredelenie sudebnoj kollegii po ugolovnym delam oblastnogo suda ot 26.05.2017 g. KonsultantPlyus. Belarus (2021) / OOO «YurSpektr», Nac. centr pravovoj inform. Resp. Belarus. Minsk.

Postanovlenie Prezidiuma oblastnogo suda ot 22.04.2016 g. KonsultantPlyus. Belarus (2021) / OOO «YurSpektr», Nac. centr pravovoj inform. Resp. Belarus. Minsk.

Biryukov, P. N. (1997) Mezhdunarodnoe sotrudnichestvo v borbe s prestupnostyu i pravovaya sistema RF. Voronezh : Istoki.

Volzhenkina, V. M. (2002) Vydacha v rossijskom ugolovnom processe. Moskva : Yurlitinform.

Lowe-Rosenberg. (1999) Die Strafprozessordnung und das Gerichtsverfassungsgesetz: Grosskommentar: in 8 Bande / Hrsg. v. Riess, P. [et al.]. 25., neubearb. Aufl. Berlin : de Gruyter, 1997–2005. Band 1: Einleitung; §§ 1 bis 71.

Krey, V. (2006) Deutsches Strafverfahrensrecht: in 2 Bande. Stuttgart : Kohlhammer.

Grishin, D. A. (2020) Mezhdunarodnye standarty ugolovnogo sudoproizvodstva. Yuridicheskaya nauka i pravoohranitelnaya praktika, 1, 65–74.

Shestakova, T. D. (2012) Ob uchastii inostrannyh grazhdan i lic bez grazhdanstva v rossijskom ugolovnom processe. Probely v rossijskom zakonodatelstve, 1, 205–207.

Dogovor mezhdu Respublikoj Belarus i Litovskoj Respublikoj o pravovoj pomoshi i pravovyh otnosheniyah po grazhdanskim, semejnym i ugolovnym delam ot 20.10.1992 g. (1993) Vedamasci Vyarhoўnaga Saveta Respubliki Belarus, 17, 202.

Andrejchik, N. I., et al. (2014) Nauchno-prakticheskij kommentarij k Ugolovno-processualnomu kodeksu Respubliki Belarus. Minsk : Akad. MVD.

Immunitet dolzhnostnyh lic gosudarstva ot inostrannoj ugolovnoj yurisdikcii / Doklad Komissii mezhdunarodnogo prava o rabote ee shestdesyat tretej sessii. (N.d.) Retrieved from International Law Commission: https://bit.ly/399rBME.

Litvishko, P. A. (2014) Osushestvlenie ugolovno-processualnoj yurisdikcii v zarubezhnyh predstavitelstvah gosudarstv. Moskva.

Fisenko, V. N. (2009) Konsulskie konvencii. Belorusskaya yuridicheskaya enciklopediya (v 4 t., t. 2. p. 103). Minsk : GIUST BGU.

Plyahimovich, I. I. (2015) Kommentarij k Konstitucii Respubliki Belarus (v 2 t., t. 1). Minsk : Amalfeya.

O primenenii sudami obshej yurisdikcii obshepriznannyh principov i norm mezhdunarodnogo prava i mezhdunarodnyh dogovorov RF. Postanovlenie Plenuma Verhovnogo Suda RF ot 10.10.2003 g. № 5. KonsultantPlyus. Rossiya / ZAO «Konsultant Plyus». Moskva, 2021.

Vasilevich, G. A. (2005) Konstituciya Respubliki Belarus: nauchno-prakticheskij kommentarij. Minsk : GIUST BGU.

Truncevskij, Yu. V.; Cvetkov, A. A. (2005) Sposoby inkorporacii mezhdunarodno-pravovyh norm v rossijskoj ugolovno-pravovoj sisteme. Mezhdunarodnoe publichnoe i chastnoe pravo, 2, 27–58.

Published
2021-12-30
Section
International Law